BPadvertisementfrom

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Wednesday, 7 November 2012

Hail to the quants, pundit fail

Posted on 04:35 by Unknown
Pundit idiocracy: "Close race", "Too close to call", "Neck and neck". (I heard this all day long.)

Quants and data geeks: "Obama will win. Unlikely to be close."

From an earlier post High V, Low M:
high verbal ability ... is useful for appearing to be smart, or for winning arguments and impressing other people, but it's really high math ability that is useful for discovering things about the world -- that is, discovering truth or reasoning rigorously.

... The statistical techniques used to analyze data obtained in a messy, complex world require mathematical ability to practice correctly. In almost all realistic circumstances hypothesis testing is intrinsically mathematical.
See also Obama wins! and Expert Prediction. Scorecard of predictions here (accuracy highly correlated with M, not V ;-)

Who is this guy?
Xu Cheng, Moodys’ Analytics: Obama 303, Romney 235 (Note that this prediction was made back in February) “This prediction is tied to the Moody’s Analytics current baseline forecast for U.S. growth, which assumes that most states will continue to recover at slow to moderate speeds.”


Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Posted in american society, bounded rationality, expert prediction, psychometrics, quants | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • Beanbags and causal variants
    Not only do these results implicate common causal variants as the source of heritability in disease susceptibility, but they also suggest th...
  • News from Microsoft Research Faculty Summit 2013
    Measuring the maximal commuting subset of observables uniquely determines the pure state of a quantum system (recently proved Kadison-Singer...
  • "Only he was fully awake"
    A great quote from this review of George Dyson's Turing's Cathedral . Despite the title, von Neumann is the central character. ... ...
  • Talk cancelled
    This talk has been cancelled, for complex reasons that I will not discuss.
  • Swedish height in the 20th century
    Average height of Swedish military conscripts during the 20th century. Looks like an increase of roughly 1 cm per decade or about 1.5 SD in ...
  • MSU photos 2
    Touring a new building with the deans and provost. MSU vs Boise State from the skyboxes. QB play was a bit shaky for the Spartans.
  • O Rio de Janeiro
    A 1986 book of Bruce Weber photographs taken in Rio de Janeiro. Weber brought some of his own models, but Rickson Gracie and family appear i...
  • Helter Skelter
    This is a great interview. I was a kid in the late 60s and early 70s, so dimly aware of and terrified by Manson and  Helter Skelter . Appare...
  • The differences are enormous
    Luis Alvarez laid it out bluntly: The world of mathematics and theoretical physics is hierarchical. That was my first exposure to it. There...
  • Science and the Humanities
    Steve Pinker: Science Is Not Your Enemy, An impassioned plea to neglected novelists, embattled professors, and tenure-less historians. New R...

Categories

  • ability (2)
  • academia (9)
  • affirmative action (8)
  • ai (13)
  • aig (1)
  • alan turing (3)
  • algorithms (2)
  • alpha (2)
  • american society (54)
  • art (3)
  • ashkenazim (1)
  • aspergers (4)
  • athletics (6)
  • autism (4)
  • autobiographical (13)
  • basketball (4)
  • bayes (1)
  • behavioral economics (4)
  • berkeley (5)
  • bgi (24)
  • biology (23)
  • biotech (6)
  • bjj (5)
  • black holes (4)
  • blade runner (2)
  • blogging (3)
  • books (5)
  • borges (2)
  • bounded rationality (10)
  • brainpower (57)
  • bubbles (3)
  • caltech (14)
  • cambridge uk (1)
  • careers (18)
  • charles darwin (1)
  • chet baker (2)
  • China (25)
  • christmas (1)
  • class (2)
  • cognitive science (35)
  • cold war (1)
  • complexity (1)
  • computing (9)
  • conferences (4)
  • cosmology (4)
  • creativity (3)
  • credit crisis (10)
  • crossfit (5)
  • cryptography (2)
  • data mining (4)
  • dating (2)
  • demographics (1)
  • derivatives (5)
  • determinism (1)
  • digital books (1)
  • dna (4)
  • economic history (5)
  • economics (38)
  • econtalk (2)
  • ecosystems (1)
  • education (5)
  • efficient markets (8)
  • Einstein (2)
  • elitism (14)
  • encryption (1)
  • energy (1)
  • entrepreneurs (3)
  • entropy (1)
  • environmentalism (1)
  • eugene (3)
  • evolution (19)
  • expert prediction (6)
  • fake alpha (2)
  • feminism (2)
  • Fermi problems (2)
  • feynman (7)
  • film (9)
  • finance (42)
  • fitness (3)
  • flynn effect (1)
  • foo camp (1)
  • football (5)
  • france (1)
  • free will (1)
  • freeman dyson (2)
  • fx (2)
  • game theory (1)
  • geeks (2)
  • gender (4)
  • genetic engineering (15)
  • genetics (79)
  • genius (24)
  • genomics (2)
  • geopolitics (7)
  • gilded age (13)
  • global warming (1)
  • globalization (23)
  • godel (2)
  • goldman sachs (2)
  • google (4)
  • happiness (2)
  • harvard (8)
  • harvard society of fellows (5)
  • hedge funds (4)
  • hedonic treadmill (1)
  • height (2)
  • higher education (38)
  • history (8)
  • history of science (12)
  • hormones (3)
  • hugh everett (2)
  • human capital (34)
  • humor (1)
  • income inequality (21)
  • india (2)
  • industrial revolution (1)
  • innovation (38)
  • intellectual history (10)
  • intellectual property (1)
  • intellectual ventures (1)
  • internet (4)
  • iq (16)
  • italy (4)
  • james salter (3)
  • japan (4)
  • jiujitsu (8)
  • keynes (1)
  • kids (13)
  • lewontin fallacy (1)
  • lhc (1)
  • literature (12)
  • luck (1)
  • machine learning (8)
  • malcolm gladwell (1)
  • manhattan (2)
  • many worlds (10)
  • mathematics (14)
  • meritocracy (7)
  • microsoft (2)
  • mma (10)
  • monsters (2)
  • moore's law (1)
  • movies (9)
  • MSU (18)
  • music (5)
  • mutants (2)
  • nathan myhrvold (1)
  • neal stephenson (1)
  • neanderthals (2)
  • nerds (3)
  • net worth (5)
  • neuroscience (7)
  • new yorker (1)
  • nicholas metropolis (1)
  • noam chomsky (2)
  • nobel prize (2)
  • nsa (2)
  • nuclear weapons (5)
  • obama (7)
  • olympics (4)
  • oppenheimer (7)
  • patents (1)
  • personality (9)
  • philip k. dick (1)
  • philosophy of mind (2)
  • photos (40)
  • physical training (13)
  • physics (73)
  • podcasts (10)
  • political correctness (6)
  • politics (4)
  • pop culture (2)
  • prisoner's dilemma (1)
  • privacy (2)
  • probability (5)
  • prostitution (2)
  • psychology (25)
  • psychometrics (31)
  • qcd (1)
  • quants (9)
  • quantum computers (2)
  • quantum field theory (3)
  • quantum mechanics (18)
  • race relations (10)
  • real estate (1)
  • realpolitik (6)
  • renaissance technologies (1)
  • research (3)
  • russia (2)
  • sad but true (2)
  • sci fi (8)
  • science (42)
  • sec (1)
  • security (5)
  • silicon valley (6)
  • singularity (1)
  • smpy (1)
  • social networks (2)
  • social science (12)
  • software development (2)
  • solar energy (1)
  • sports (13)
  • startups (19)
  • statistics (16)
  • success (2)
  • taiwan (1)
  • talks (16)
  • teaching (2)
  • technology (34)
  • television (2)
  • travel (24)
  • turing test (1)
  • ufc (8)
  • ultimate fighting (1)
  • universities (33)
  • university of oregon (6)
  • usain bolt (2)
  • venture capital (3)
  • volatility (1)
  • von Neumann (10)
  • wall street (2)
  • war (1)
  • warren buffet (1)
  • wwii (3)

Blog Archive

  • ►  2013 (134)
    • ►  August (10)
    • ►  July (15)
    • ►  June (22)
    • ►  May (20)
    • ►  April (21)
    • ►  March (18)
    • ►  February (14)
    • ►  January (14)
  • ▼  2012 (222)
    • ►  December (17)
    • ▼  November (19)
      • The Myth of American Meritocracy
      • Persistence, motivation and reliability
      • Schwinger on quantum foundations
      • DC photos
      • Fed town
      • Michigan startups
      • F > L > P > S
      • The benevolence of financiers
      • All In
      • Training days
      • Broad Art Museum
      • Global fashion equilibration
      • "They take students like you there."
      • Hail to the quants, pundit fail
      • Obama wins!
      • MSU photos 6
      • Magical Mystery MOOCs
      • "The bar is different ..."
      • Quants and campaigns
    • ►  October (20)
    • ►  September (25)
    • ►  August (19)
    • ►  July (18)
    • ►  June (16)
    • ►  May (20)
    • ►  April (16)
    • ►  March (18)
    • ►  February (20)
    • ►  January (14)
  • ►  2011 (144)
    • ►  December (20)
    • ►  November (16)
    • ►  October (25)
    • ►  September (23)
    • ►  August (21)
    • ►  July (26)
    • ►  June (13)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

Unknown
View my complete profile